Butcher In ICU

Dear Mr. Dhoni,

All we cricket fans, particularly Indian cricket fans, will eagerly look forward to the Old Trafford Test that begins tomorrow.  And look forward with some amount of trepidation as well. 

You are indeed someone with the most coolest and calculating brain in the cricketing fraternity today.  You do think and act out of the box, and we have seen some fabulous successes in the past. Who can forget your own batting promotion ahead of Yuvraj in the World Cup 2011 with stunning success!

Why then do you get into a completely defensive mindset in Test cricket Mr. Dhoni? The 2011 Dominica Test against the West Indies when you opted not go after 86 runs in 15 overs with 7 wickets in hand still rankles a few of us who want to see India as a dominant champion side.

Much has been said about this series and the three Tests till date, and it doesn’t warrant a recall.  But the key question that bothers many of us is, how will Mahendra Singh Dhoni approach this Test? Yes, there are injury concerns but we have a big squad and replacements, who if not the ideal, are available.  And the guys on the bench have earned their place to be there.  The key question is will you enter the field with a view to win the game? Will the bowlers perform as an ‘attack’ or will it be a ‘squad’ with a defensive mindset and orientation right from the word go? 

We accept a failure with the bat or ball or even a poor performance in the field. We understand that everyone has talent as well as limitations and it isn’t an utopian existence for anyone, where everything goes well for us and everyone performs to his ability.  In fact when in trouble on difficult wickets and you come into bat, we feel as anxious as a crowd outside a hospital ICU where a butcher has arrived in place of a heart surgeon to perform a life saving procedure.  Yet, we still hope that youwould battle it out, for if not the technique you have the grit and determination in addition to a smart brain. So, win or loss is not an issue at the end of the day. It is the effort and approach that matters in the first place.  If that is in the right earnest, the changes for success are manifold.

So please Mr Dhoni, approach this Test the way you approach the shorter version of the games!  If the T20 and ODI games had an option for a draw, you perhaps would have topped the list of such games as captain with the most number of drawn T20/ODI games!  But you have better mettle and we are hoping to see a Test where we don’t end up feeling ashamed a non-performance as in the last game!

Thank you!

Die Trying!

In sporting encounters, there is only one winner.  There also exists the view that what matters more is the participation than winning or losing in a competitive arena. Fans are also not averse to putting together their hands to applaud their team even if the team hasn’t been successful. What makes sports endearing is the action on the field and the joy it brings to those watching it. 

When a young Indian team came up with a stirring win at Lords’ just a week ago, Indian cricket fans were overjoyed, and with good reason.  Conditions were quite not in their favour and the manner of the win was also one where aggression and game plan worked well. Had India lost, it would perhaps have been accepted as a game where the odds were stacked against them and they lacked experience.  Euphoria prevailed not just over the win, but the thought that this team was now growing in maturity and confidence.  Was this the beginning of a new era? A new found confidence that would erase the bitter memories of many a past overseas tour outside the subcontinent?  Yes, only time would tell.

India came into Ageas Bowl Test with more aspects in their favour than the home side.  Alastair Cook, the England skipper was under the hammer. The experienced batsmen in the line-up were under question. Key strike bowler Stuart Broad suspected of playing with a knee injury. Matt Prior had stepped down after the Lords defeat. The English side was a in a free-fall with no win in the last 10 Test, the previous Test victory having come in August 2013. India had to deal the knock-out blow to bury England.  The only negative, if any, had been the docking of Ravindra Jadeja with a match fine stemming from the Anderson/Ravindra Jadeja incident.

How did India and England approach this game?  England won the toss and decided to bat first, which, before the game started, was seen as a bold move both by a side that was on a winless streak and by a captain battling for form.  True, India were without their spearhead Ishant Sharma.  Great sides are those that overcome adversities to emerge with honours.  Not those who requires the best of everything to come up winners.  The defensive line that Ravindra Jadeja bowled on the first day was a clear indicator of the mindset of the India side.  True, the catch that Jadeja dropped to give Alastair Cook a real ‘life’ and probably the first innings stroke that led to the dismissal of Rohit Sharma may arguably be seen as two critical incidents that led to the humiliating loss for India.  But did a side that start a Test with four bowlers of whom one was assigned to a negative role really deserve to win? 

If India had it’s legs at the throat of England after the Lords Test, not just did it weaken it’s hold but stopped low enough to allow Engalnd to grab it where it hurt the most.  Players may perform remarkably or have failures.  No one deliberately fails, one trusts, in these days and times.  When a side that had everything going in its favour begins a game with no intent to win, it deserved the humiliation Engalnd handed them.  You may be weak but you will still get some respect if you die trying. India have not just lost a Test but also all respect, perhaps.  The weeks ahead will tell if the Ageas Bowl Test was an aberration or perhaps reinforce that feeling that India are presently being led by a think tank with an utterly negative mindset that refuses to throw the first punch and lurks like a weakling to catch a weak prey.